Hiring domestic help can make day-to-day life easier, but the right arrangement depends on what a household needs. A live-in helper may support a wider range of agreed household duties; part-time help is booked for set services and hours.
Salary and hourly rates tell only part of the story. A fair comparison also considers levies, food, insurance, accommodation, recruitment, privacy and the time involved in managing an employment relationship.
Using the estimates in this guide, a live-in arrangement costs about S$1,125–S$1,495 a month before one-time recruitment expenses. Recurring part-time cleaning at S$18–S$23 an hour may cost less when a household needs only a few hours of help each week. These are planning examples, not fixed prices.
Live-in helper or part-time help: the main differences
| Consideration | Live-in domestic helper | Part-time household service |
|---|---|---|
| How you pay | Monthly salary plus levy and household-related expenses. | Usually charged by the hour or by a service package. |
| What support can cover | Agreed daily duties may include cleaning, cooking, laundry and household support for children or older family members, depending on the arrangement. | A defined service during booked hours, such as cleaning. Other tasks depend on the provider and service scope. |
| Who employs the worker | The household takes on the direct employer responsibilities and Work Permit administration. | With a Household Services Scheme (HSS) provider, the service company employs and deploys its workers. |
| Accommodation and privacy | Suitable living space must be provided, and another adult lives in the home. | No live-in accommodation is needed; the household retains its living space. |
| Flexibility | Support is available for agreed duties; changing the arrangement takes discussion and planning. | Hours and visit frequency can often be adjusted to the household's needs and provider availability. |
| Best fit | Households needing regular, broader daily assistance. | Households that mainly need cleaning or occasional, clearly scoped tasks. |
What does a live-in helper cost each month?
The following illustration assumes one helper and a S$600–S$800 salary. Actual pay is agreed between employer and employee and varies with experience, skills, responsibilities and other terms. Singapore does not set one universal minimum salary for migrant domestic workers.
| Recurring expense | Illustrative monthly amount |
|---|---|
| Salary | S$600–S$800 |
| Foreign worker levy, normal rate | S$300 |
| Food and household provisions | S$150–S$250 |
| Medical and personal accident insurance | S$25–S$45 |
| Medical expenses and routine checks budget | S$20–S$50 |
| Other household expenses | S$30–S$50 |
| Estimated recurring total | S$1,125–S$1,495 |
These are household budgeting estimates, not statutory fees. Insurance premiums, food and medical spending vary. Suitable accommodation is also required, but no separate cash figure is included here because the cost depends on the home and living arrangements.
Upfront costs and replacement risk
Recruitment and administrative costs may include agency or placement fees of about S$1,000–S$2,500, Work Permit fees, a medical examination, insurance arrangements and travel. Check what an agency package includes before signing.
The S$5,000 security bond for a non-Malaysian helper is a financial guarantee arranged through a bank or insurer, not a S$5,000 recruitment expense. If a helper leaves and the household needs a replacement, additional recruitment and travel costs may arise; refunds depend on the agency's terms.
How much does part-time cleaning cost?
For recurring cleaning, the supplied provider examples range from S$18 to S$23 per hour before GST. The monthly estimates below use 4.33 weeks per month; add GST, service fees or surcharges where they are not already included.
| Cleaning hours each week | Approximate monthly hours | Estimated monthly cost before GST |
|---|---|---|
| 3 hours | 13 | S$234–S$299 |
| 4 hours | 17.3 | S$312–S$399 |
| 6 hours | 26 | S$468–S$598 |
| 8 hours | 34.7 | S$624–S$797 |
| 10 hours | 43.3 | S$780–S$997 |
| 12 hours | 52 | S$936–S$1,196 |
| 15 hours | 65 | S$1,170–S$1,495 |
As one simple example, a four-hour visit at S$18 per hour is S$72. At four visits in a month, that is S$288 before GST, or S$313.92 with 9% GST.
A like-for-like monthly budget example
To illustrate the difference, compare a live-in arrangement budgeted at about S$1,300 a month with recurring cleaning at S$18 an hour plus 9% GST. The part-time estimates use 4.33 weeks per month.
| Arrangement | Approximate monthly cost | Approximate annual cost |
|---|---|---|
| Live-in helper | S$1,300 | S$15,600 |
| 3-hour weekly cleaning | S$255 | S$3,060 |
| 6-hour weekly cleaning | S$510 | S$6,120 |
| 9-hour weekly cleaning | S$764 | S$9,168 |
| 12-hour weekly cleaning | S$1,019 | S$12,228 |
This is an illustration, not a promise of savings. It compares a broad live-in arrangement with cleaning hours only; the services are not equivalent. A cleaner booked for a few hours cannot be expected to take on a helper's wider agreed duties.
When the concessionary levy changes the calculation
For households that qualify, the example in the supplied material uses a S$60 monthly concessionary levy instead of S$300. That is S$240 less each month, or S$2,880 over a year. Under the same illustrative assumptions, the live-in monthly estimate would fall to about S$885–S$1,255. Check current eligibility with MOM before relying on this figure.
Costs that do not fit neatly into a table
- Privacy and space: A live-in arrangement changes household routines and requires suitable accommodation. Some families value the arrangement; others prefer not to share their home.
- Employer time: Direct employment involves communication, supervision, welfare and handling employment matters.
- Continuity: A helper may become familiar to children or older relatives. A change of worker can affect the household emotionally as well as practically.
- Service limits: Part-time bookings cover a defined service. Check what is included, whether the same cleaner can return, and how cancellations or damage are handled.
Which arrangement might suit your household?
Working couple needing occasional cleaning
If the main need is a few hours of cleaning each week and there is no regular childcare or elder support requirement, part-time bookings may be the simpler, lower-cost fit.
Family needing daily household support
When the household needs regular help with several agreed duties, such as cooking, laundry, cleaning and childcare support, a live-in arrangement may provide broader coverage.
Household supporting an older relative
Match the service to the person's needs. Basic companionship or assistance is different from bathing, medication, mobility or medical care; specialist care may be more appropriate for those needs.
Family that qualifies for the concessionary levy
A lower levy can make live-in help more affordable, particularly when the household uses a wider range of daily support. Confirm eligibility and current rates first.
It does not have to be either-or
Some households use a live-in helper for regular daily duties and book a professional service for occasional deep cleaning. Families may also consider childcare centres, senior day-care or professional home-care providers when their needs go beyond household tasks.
The bottom line
Part-time help can be more economical when a household needs only a few hours of cleaning each week. A live-in helper can make more sense when the family needs broader, regular daily support and is prepared to take on direct employment responsibilities.
Choose based on the tasks, hours, budget, privacy and care requirements—not salary or hourly rate alone. The best-value arrangement is the one that meets the household's actual needs without paying for support it will not use.
Sources
- Ministry of Manpower – Foreign Domestic Worker Levy
- Ministry of Manpower – Security Bond Requirements
- Ministry of Manpower – Insurance Requirements
- Ministry of Manpower – Thinking of Hiring a Domestic Helper?
- Ministry of Manpower – Household Services Scheme
- Luce – Home Cleaning Prices
- Helpling – Cleaning Services and Rates
Costs are illustrative estimates from the supplied article material. Eligibility, fees and provider prices can change; check current MOM guidance and service terms before making a decision.
Where to verify: This article is general editorial information, not legal, immigration, medical or financial advice. Requirements can change. Check the relevant Singapore government agency or a qualified professional for advice about your situation.



